Thursday, May 21, 2009

The Economist on Waxman-Markey

The Economist has an article out this week that does not like the House's Waxman Markey Climate Change bill. It supports President Obama's plan that would have auctioned all credits, creating revenue the the government could then hand out as it likes. Instead, Waxman-Markey gives away 85% of its carbon credits to industy. In this way, they will recieve the windfall from this bill, not the government.

So, the Economist seems to favor tax increases, while Waxman-Markey favors corporate welfare. The article makes the good point that: "it means that the permits go not to those who value them most (as in an auction) but to those whom the government favours." Republican's (who claim to oppose both tax increases and corporate welfare) the article expects to: "berate the bill as both a job-destroyer and a handout to big business." Its hard to be both, which points to the difficulty that Republicans are having trying to craft a message on this issue.

Environmentally, all that matters, however, is that the cap is tightly put on. The rest is just how you share the money.

Wednesday, May 20, 2009

More Details from US-China Meeting

Lisa Friedman at ClimateWire has a story today about this 'secret meeting' last year.

The most interesting part to me is when Chinese Minister Xie Zhenhua said that its time to move 'beyond the rhetoric.' It is interesting to hear such a candid statement fro a Chinese Government official: in my experience, a Chinese government official is not given that much latitude to say what they want. In this case, his candor may have helped move China and the US away from their 'suicide pact.'

Tuesday, May 19, 2009

Secret US-China Talks on Climate Change

This is exciting news from the Guardian about US-China talks on what they are calling "secret talks" on a bilateral climate change agreement.

Two things that strike me about this article:

1. These talks were initiated during the Bush Administration in 2007. I contend that, by the last two years of the administration, there were some very helpful policied being put together on climate change, incuding the Asia-Pacific Partnership, the Department of Energy's Loan Guarantee program, the Major Economies Meetings, and apparently, these meetings. Unfortunately, the denials and hesitations of the previous 6 years had set the storyline, and no one was ready to believe that they could do any good on this issue. Also, these programs were very much led by Congress, not the Administration.

2. Why is this news being broken by a British newspaper? I wonder if the Obama administration had been able to convince American papers to keep a lid on it, or if the Guardian simply scooped the Washington Post and the New York Times? The Chinese can sometimes be difficult in negotiations, and I hope that this publicity doesn't undercut the good work that has been done up to now.